USMLE Step 1 practice question: Case-control study: calculating the odds ratio

USMLE Step 1BiostatisticsEpidemiology

Investigators conduct a study to determine whether occupational pesticide exposure is associated with Parkinson disease. They enroll 100 patients with Parkinson disease from a movement disorders clinic and 200 people of similar age and sex without the disease from the same community. Trained interviewers using a structured questionnaire ask each participant about past occupational exposures. Forty of the patients with Parkinson disease and 20 of the participants without the disease report at least 5 years of occupational pesticide exposure.

Which of the following is the odds ratio for the association between occupational pesticide exposure and Parkinson disease?

  1. 0.17
  2. 2.0
  3. 2.7
  4. 4.0
  5. 6.0
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: E. 6.0

This is a case-control study: participants are selected on the basis of the outcome (patients with Parkinson disease as cases, people without it as controls) and are then asked about prior exposure. Arrange the data in a 2 × 2 table: Exposed cases (a) = 40; unexposed cases (c) = 60 Exposed controls (b) = 20; unexposed controls (d) = 180 Odds ratio = (a/c) ÷ (b/d) = ad/bc = (40 × 180)/(20 × 60) = 7,200/1,200 = 6.0.

The odds of exposure among cases (40/60) are 6 times the odds of exposure among controls (20/180). Because the investigators chose how many cases and controls to enroll, the proportion of participants with disease is artificial, so incidence and relative risk cannot be calculated directly. When the disease is rare in the population, as Parkinson disease is, the odds ratio closely approximates the relative risk (the rare disease assumption).

Case-control studies are efficient for rare diseases and diseases with long latency and allow several exposures to be studied at once. Their main weaknesses are recall bias (cases may search their memories more thoroughly than controls) and selection bias in choosing controls. Trained interviewers and a structured questionnaire, as used here, help limit interviewer and recall bias.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A. 0.17 — 0.17 is the inverse of the correct ratio (bc/ad), obtained by placing the controls in the numerator.
  • B. 2.0 — 2.0 compares the number of exposed cases with the number of exposed controls (40/20), ignoring the unexposed participants.
  • C. 2.7 — 2.7 treats the data as a cohort and divides the proportion of exposed people with disease by that of unexposed people, which is invalid when the investigator fixes the case-to-control ratio.
  • D. 4.0 — 4.0 compares the proportion of cases exposed (40%) with the proportion of controls exposed (10%), a ratio of proportions rather than of odds.

Key point

In a case-control study, the odds ratio is calculated as ad/bc (odds of exposure in cases divided by odds of exposure in controls) and approximates the relative risk when the disease is rare.

Memory hook

Case-control: start with disease, look back at exposure, and report odds by cross-multiplying, ad over bc.

Share: Telegram WhatsApp X LinkedIn

Practice like this every day

15 free bank questions a day, exam-length timed blocks, spaced repetition and 3D anatomy — in English and Russian.

Play free

More free questions in this system

Positive predictive value and the effect of prevalence (2 × 2 table)USMLE Step 1 · BiostatisticsIntention-to-treat analysis preserves randomization in clinical trialsUSMLE Step 2 CK · BiostatisticsChronic aortic regurgitationUSMLE Step 1 · CardiovascularPharmacokinetics: volume of distribution and oral loading doseUSMLE Step 1 · PharmacologyAutosomal recessive recurrence risk (cystic fibrosis, unaffected sibling = 2/3 carrier)USMLE Step 1 · GeneticsAcyclovir-resistant HSV: thymidine kinase deficiencyUSMLE Step 1 · Microbiology

All free questions →